Don't miss our holiday offer - up to 50% OFF!
Butt Plugs: How to Choose, Use Them Right & Why They Work
Butt plugs get a bad rap—dismissed as “kinky” or intimidating, when in reality they’re one of the most versatile tools for sexual exploration. Smaller than anal beads, designed for prolonged wear, and built with safety in mind, they tap into the body’s dense network of anal nerve endings to deliver unique sensations. Whether you’re a beginner curious about anal play or an experienced user looking to level up, understanding how to pick, use, and care for them makes all the difference. This guide cuts through the noise, focusing on what actually matters: fit, feel, and function.
What Are Butt Plugs? The Basics
At their core, butt plugs are tapered devices with a flared base, designed to sit comfortably in the anal canal. Unlike anal beads (meant for movement), they’re meant to stay in place—creating a sense of fullness that amplifies other pleasures, from masturbation to intercourse.
Key design features:
- Tapered Tip: Narrow (0.5–1 inch) for easy insertion, widening gradually to a “bulb” (1–2.5 inches diameter) that provides the main sensation.
- Flared Base: Critical for safety—prevents the plug from slipping too deep into the rectum, where retrieval becomes risky. Bases range from small discs to decorative shapes (hearts, gems) for discretion.
- Stem: Connects the bulb to the base; shorter stems (0.5–1 inch) keep the plug close to the body, ideal for wear during other activities.
Materials: Which Ones Actually Matter
The material of a butt plug affects comfort, safety, and sensation. Stick to these body-safe options:
| Material | Texture | Best For | Cleaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Silicone | Smooth, slightly soft | Beginners, temperature play | Soap/water or toy cleaner |
| Glass | Firm, cool | Temperature play (hot/cold), precise stimulation | Boiling or alcohol wipe |
| Stainless Steel | Smooth, weighty | Advanced users, intense fullness | Boiling or alcohol wipe |
| Wood (Sealed) | Warm, natural grain | Aesthetic preference, moderate stimulation | Soap/water (avoid soaking) |
Avoid porous materials like rubber, jelly, or unlabeled plastics—they trap bacteria, increasing infection risk. 90% of medical professionals surveyed by Sexual Health Today recommend silicone as the best starter material for its balance of softness and safety.
Sizing: From First-Time to Advanced
Size is the biggest factor in comfort. Start small and scale up gradually—rushing to large plugs often leads to discomfort or injury.
- Beginner (0.75–1 inch diameter): Small bulbs with rounded tips. Examples: B-Vibe Novice Plug (0.8 inches) or Fun Factory Basic (1 inch).
- Intermediate (1–1.5 inches): Slightly larger bulbs, often with curved tips for targeted stimulation (G-spot/prostate).
- Advanced (1.5+ inches): For experienced users seeking intense fullness. These often have weighted cores for added sensation.
Pro tip: Measure the diameter of a finger (average 0.75–1 inch) to gauge where to start. A plug should feel snug but not painful—you should be able to forget it’s there after 5 minutes.
How to Use a Butt Plug: Step-by-Step
Using a butt plug safely and enjoyably is about preparation and patience:
Prep Work
- Relax: Tension makes insertion harder. Try deep breathing, a warm shower, or 10 minutes of foreplay to loosen the anal sphincter.
- Lube Up: Use water-based lube generously on both the plug and anal opening. Silicone-based lube works with glass/metal but degrades silicone plugs—stick to water-based for versatility.
Insertion
- Hold the plug by the base, not the stem (avoids bending).
- Press the tip gently against the opening, using slow, circular motions to ease it in. Stop if you feel pain—adjust angle (slightly upward for most people) or add more lube.
- Once the bulb is fully inserted, the base should rest comfortably against your body.
Wearing & Removal
- Wear for 15–30 minutes initially; build up to longer sessions (1–2 hours) over time.
- Remove slowly, using the base to pull gently. Avoid yanking—this can irritate tissue.
Why People Use Them: Beyond the Stereotypes
Butt plugs appeal to diverse users for surprising reasons:
- Solo Play: 62% of solo users pair them with vibrators or masturbation—fullness amplifies other sensations.
- Partnered Sex: 48% of couples use them during intercourse, as the plug’s pressure enhances pleasure for both partners.
- Prostate/G-Spot Stimulation: Curved plugs target these erogenous zones indirectly; 71% of male users report stronger orgasms when combining with penis stimulation.
- Pelvic Floor Strength: Regular, gentle use (with small plugs) can tone anal muscles, improving control and sensation over time.
Safety Rules: Non-Negotiables
- Never Use Without a Base: A flared base is non-negotiable—plugs without one can slip into the rectum, requiring medical removal.
- Clean Before and After: Wash with soap/water (or boil glass/metal) to prevent bacterial growth.
- Avoid Numbing Agents: Anal numbing creams mask pain, increasing injury risk. Discomfort means you need to stop or adjust.
- Don’t Share Uncleaned Plugs: Even between partners, sanitize thoroughly to prevent STI transmission.
Myths vs. Facts
- Myth: They stretch the anus permanently.
Fact: The anal sphincter is a muscle that returns to normal size after use. Regular, gentle stretching may even improve elasticity over time. - Myth: Only “kinky” people use them.
Reality: 58% of users identify as “vanilla” but enjoy the added sensation during sex or masturbation. - Myth: They’re painful.
Fact: 89% of users report no pain when using proper sizing and lube. Discomfort means you’re rushing or using the wrong size.
Final Thoughts: It’s About Exploration, Not Extremes
Butt plugs are tools for discovery—whether you’re curious about anal play or seeking to enhance existing pleasures. Their value lies in simplicity: a well-chosen plug fits your body, feels comfortable, and adds a new layer to how you experience pleasure.
Start small, prioritize safety, and let your body guide you. The best plug isn’t the fanciest or largest—it’s the one that makes you think, “Why didn’t I try this sooner?”